Categories

Login

Education >>>

Malaysia history textbook is just a piece of junk

There are tons of historical errors in the Malaysia history textbook. I point out a few examples come across in my mind.

– Parameswara never converted to Islam as written in the textbook.

– Hang Tuah and his gang are all illusionary characters, there is no historical evidence to prove they are real characters.

– Hang Li Poh is not a princess from China, no official document in the Ming Dynasty said Hang Li Poh is a real princess.

– The majority of Malay were cohorts working for Japanese Imperial Army during the World War 2 is downplayed.

– Chinese played important role in the resistance against Japanese occupation is ignored.

UMNO goons distorted historical fact to make Malay looks significant while downplay or even malign other races as the traitor.

History textbooks biased, say writers

by Zakiah Koya

Ranjit was labelled as "anti national" when he pointed out the errors and distortions in history textbooks.

PETALING JAYA (Dec 12, 2010): History textbooks are biased and littered with errors, claim two authors and academicians. Dr Ranjit Singh Malhi and Ng How Kuen, who writes history textbooks for Chinese schools, say their experience with officialdom does not augur well for the teaching of history in our classrooms.

Ranjit, author of secondary school history textbooks since 1990, and adviser to the Ministry of Education (MOE) on history textbooks, said such material were littered with factual errors and distortions. He said that when he pointed out the errors and distortions, a ministry official labelled him “anti-national”.

“Secondary school history textbooks have been used to promote political interests. It should be a scholarly pursuit and not politically-motivated,” said Ranjit who showed theSun history textbooks with errors and exaggerated facts.

“Five out of 10 chapters of the Form Four history textbook deal with Islamic history as compared to only one chapter in the earlier textbook. The intention of the earlier syllabus was to expose our students to World History,” he said when commenting on the announcement that the history syllabus is being reviewed and that the subject will be made a compulsory pass in the Sijil
Pelajaran Malaysia from 2013.

“The coverage of important historical events such as Renaissance and Industrial Revolution has been reduced by more than half,” he said.

He also said certain historical personalities, such as Yap Ah Loy (the third Kapitan China of Kuala Lumpur), were not given due recognition. Yap played a major role in the development of Kuala Lumpur as a commercial and tin-mining centre, particularly after the fire of 1881,” he said, adding that the Form Two history textbook had only one sentence on Yap as “one of the persons
responsible for developing Kuala Lumpur”.

“There is also no mention of freedom fighters such as Gurchan Singh (“Lion of Malaya”) and Sybil Karthigesu who resisted the Japanese Occupation of Malaya,” he said. (Gurchan secretly distributed a newspaper during the Japanese occupation while Sybil, who was tortured by the Japanese, and her husband treated wounded guerillas of the Malayan People’s Anti-Japanese Army).

The most glaring example of bias, he said, was related to the downfall of the Malay Sultanate of Malacca.

“The 1996 Form One textbook stated inter alia that a few Indian merchants lent their junks to the Portuguese in their attack on Malacca. I know of no historical evidence to support this fact,” said Ranjit.

“Six Chinese captains agreed to lend their junks to the Portuguese due to their hatred for Sultan Mahmud who had earlier detained them and their men to help attack Aru. The Portuguese used only one junk provided by one of the Chinese,” he said.

Ranjit pointed out that the decision to make history a must pass subject for SPM from 2013 was rooted in a wrong premise. “It is not right to assume that students will study history seriously and will be more patriotic after clearly understanding the Federal Constitution and the social contract.

“Patriotism thrives when citizens have a ‘sense of belonging’ and perceive themselves being treated equitably,” he said.

Ng, meanwhile, fears that making history a compulsory pass subject would mean one would have to subscribe to one’s version of events or risk failing the entire examination.

Ng, whose textbooks are still used in Chinese-medium primary schools, however stressed that it was timely to review the syllabus. “We always had to follow the curriculum given by the MOE and therefore the ruling parties have the upper hand in defining our history.”

As an example, he said when writing on the fight for independence, the contributions of the communists were left out.

He said history books should be written by historians and not teachers as the former were not bound by the curriculum. “Students do know the truth but as textbooks are written according to approved curriculum, students end up learning history that is skewed,” said Ng. — theSun

The nkkhoo.com comment board with Facebook account.
hassan ali says:

umno shall fall gracefully . orang asli are original people of malaya. kadazans for sabah and dayaks for sarawak.so umno goon donot tell grandfather story.No malaysia without sabah and sarawak.umno goons.

kiko says:

I’m glad that Chinese come out with this fake history, by doing that they indirectly working for UMNO/BN by making more and more Malays hate them for trying to change history of Malaysia. Well, Malays, if you want Tanah Melayu be called as Bar Chin, vote for DAP, PKR and PAS. At least MCA know their place in this country. Good job NKKHOO.

nkkhoo says:

UMNO racists have been launching hatred Chinese campaign for 50 years, the peak of campaign is 513 massacre against Chinese.

Go blame others for your own evil and hope your God will pardon you in the jugdement day.

matwan says:

MPAJA was invited to London and KL for the WW2 victory parade. My blog has video to prove this statement.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TqwAvS7jJYA

SURELY THEY WERE INVITED BY THE BRITISH FOR THE PARADE BECAUSE THEY WERE FRIENDS (FOR FIGHT AGAINST JAPANESE) ENEMY OF MY ENEMY IS MY FRIEND. AMERICAN ALSO TEAMED UP WITH RUSSIAN AGAINST NAZI GERMANY. WHY DONT U STATE THAT CPM INVOLVED IN WAR AGAINST BRITSH MALAYAN GOVERNMENT FOR 12 YEARS.

CMP is like Malay nationalists siding the wrong side in the cold war.

A book written by a Chinese does not give more weight to your own history. If MPAJA did kill Malays for fun, UMNO is the first party to make use of “Chinese brutality” as their tool to influence Malays”

SURELY IT DOES ADD THE WEIGHT, THAT PROFESSOR CHEAH BOON KHENG IS A RESPECTABLE PROFESSOR, NOT LIKE YOU A CHAUVINIST MINDED CHINESE WHOSE BLOG ONLY READ BY A FEW PEOPLE.

Prof. Khoo Kay Kim is a reputable local historian than others. I take his words until you proven otherwise.

Without the 50,000 troops from British, Australia and New Zealand came to Malaya, your Malay heroic ancestors have no way to defeat communist insurgents.

THAT 50K WHITESMAN SOLDIERS ALSO WOULD HAVE NOT SUCCEED AGAINST COMMUNIST FORCE WITHOUT THE HELP OF HUNDREDS OF THOUSANDS OF POLICE JUNGLE SQUAD, AUXILLIARY POLICEMAN, SPECIAL CONSTABLE AND HOMEGUARDS (MOST OF THEM ARE MALAY-MUSLIMS)!!!!

A racist is always a racist, my father was a home guard. Do you want the proof? Malaysian government recognized my late father contribution by granting a small sum money to my family recently.

HEY MR NK KHOO, I DON NOT KNOW YOU REALLY THIS UNKNOWLEDGEBLE! REGARDING THE MALAY WARRIORS, IM NOT TALKING ABOUT 12 YEARS INSURGENCY FROM 1948-1960, IM TALKING ABOUT 15 DAYS CHINESE COMMUNIST REIGN OF TERROR IN MALAYA FROM 15 AUGUST 1945 – 3 SEPTEMBER 1945. A PERIOD OF POWER VACUUM, WHEN THE JAPANESE TROOPS ALREADY SURRENDUR AND BEGIN TO WITHDRAW TO LARGER CITY AND BRITISH FORCES DOESNT ARRIVE YET, AT THAT TIME YOUR BLOODTHIRSTY AND POWER HUNGRY IDOL OF BINTANG TIGA COME OUT FROM JUNGLE TO TAKE OVER SMALL TOWN, AND VILLAGE, (ABOUT 70 % OF MALAYAN SMALL TOWN AND VILLAGE IN THEIR HAND). HOWEVER ALMOST ALL ATTEMPTS BY COMMUNIST GUERILLAS TO TO TAKE OVER MALAY TOWNS AND VILLAGES FAILED DUE TO WITH FIERCE RESISTANCE, AND FIERCEST FIGTHING TOOK PLACE IN BATU PAHAT, MUAR AND ALSO LOWER PERAK.
SURELY THESE MALAY MARTIAL ART GROUP ARE NOT GOING TO TO TOTALLY DEFEAT COMMUNIST INSURGENT BECAUSE THEY WERE NOT TRAINED SOLDIER. THEY JUST ONLY SIMPLE DEVOUT MUSLIM VILLAGERS WHO WERE FORCE TO TAKE UP ARM TO DEFEND THEIR HOME AND FAMILY AND RELIGION FROM BINTANG TIGA’S ATROCITIES. YEA THEY MIGHT NOT DEFEAT MPAJA TOTALLY, BUT THEY MANAGE TO:
– DEFEND MALAYS’ AREA (NO MPAJA GUERRILA OR ARMED CHINESE DARE TO ENTER MALAY VILLAGE)
– CHASE OUT EVERY COMMUNIST INSURGENT INTO THE JUNGLE SO SO THE COMMUNIST COULD NOT LAUNCH LARGE SCALE ATTACK AGAIN, THE COMMUNIST ONLY DARE TO KILL LONLEY MALAYS, CARRIED OUT ABDUCT OF MALAY MAN AND WOMAN AND ASSASINATION ONLY)
– CARRIED PUNITIVE RAIDS EVERY TIME CHINESE GUERRILA AND THUGS ATTACK MALAU MUSLIM PEOPLE, THEY MANAGE TO CLEAR OUT LARGE AREA IN BATU PAHAT AND SOUTH WESTER JOHOR OF MPAJA/CHINESE ELEMENT. IN SUNGAI MANIK PERAK, ENTIRE CHINESE POPULATION HAD TO FLEE THE SUNGAI PERAK BASIN AREA AFTER FACING FORCEFUL, MALAY-MUSLIM COUNTERATTACK DUE TO MURDER OF MANY MALAYS BY THE CHINESE GUERRILLA.

SO FOR AN ARMY THAT ONLY ARMED WITH TRADITIONAL COLD STEAL WEAPON, ITS ABILTY TO FOIL ATTACK BY ENEMIES ARMED WITH VARIOUS FIREARMED (PISTOL, GUN, RIFLE, AUTOMATIC AMCHINEGUN) AND INFLICT HEAVY CAUSALTIES ON THEM WIOULD CONSIDERED AS REMARKABLE ACHIEVEMENT!!!

I still awaiting your evidence. Prof Khoo is also waiting people like you to come forward to provide him evidence.

‘Most UMNO leaders are non-Malay blood, they have to instigate local native Malays to hate Chinese for them to grasp power as what the China communist party did in China. Chinese Muslims in China are treated badly as UMNO treats Malaysian Chinese’

SEKARANG NI KALAU MEREKA ADA DARAH BUKAN MELAYU PUN APA MASALAHNYA, MEREKA MENGANGGAP DIRI MEREKA SEBAGAI MELAYU, HABIS TU, KALAU MEREKA TAK MENGAMBIL KUASA, NAK BAGI KAT SIAPA KUASA?/ BAGI DEKAT CINA BINTANG TIGA?
DAN TAK PAYAH BUAT PERBANDINGAN CINA MALAYSIA DAN CINA MUSLIM DI NEGARA CHINA. APA YANG KAMU RASA UMNO BUAT NI LANGSUNG TAK SETARA MANA DENGAN APA YANG CINA KMUNIS BUAT KEPADA CINA MUSLIM. MUNGKIN UMNO ADA MELEBIHKAN ORANG MELAYU DALAM BANYAK PERKARA, TAPI SEKURANG SSEKURANG NYA UMNO TAK PERNAH MENGGANGGU APA YANG ORANG CINA HENDAK BUAT, KAMU HENDAK BERNIAGA, BUKA KEDAI JUDI NAK BERDISKO, ATAU NAK MELAKSANAKAN AMAL IBADAT KAMU, TAK ADA SIAPA YANG HALANG. TAPI D CHINA , UMAT ISLAM CHINA BUKAN SAHAJA, DITINDAS, MALAH NAK BERSEMBAHYANG AN BERPUASA PUN TAK BOLEH, ADA KAMU LIHAT ORANG CINA DEKAT SINI TIBA TIBA DITANGKAP POLIS? TAK ADA KAN.

I prefer to give power to PAS and PKR. Those mamak should be kicked out from the political circle.

A communist is a communist, you are purposely link the CPM revolt as a war between Chinese against Malay. The CPM chairman is a Malay nationalist and his son, Kamal was given citizenship by UMNO government.

A classmate in kampung was beatan till half dead by a Malay policeman, the incident was brought to parliament in 80s by Lim Kit Siang. The policeman was not punished at the end.

How about another case reported in the yesterday’s papers?

matwan says:

Malay ancestors were chased out from Southern Vietnam by Vietnamese at about 1000 years ago, then forced to move to Riau Archipelago and Java Island. Then around 600 years ago moved to Malay Peninsula and managed to control Malay Peninsula under the assistance and protection from China Ming dynasty.

“This Malay bigot is twisting history again. No such nation called Nusantara in the history. That was a Malay empire called Johor in the Nusantara.

Indonesia was under the control of Dutch people. Legally speaking, your ancestors were illegal immigrants unlike my ancestors who were brought in by British and Johor Sultan as legal immigrants.

If you think late Johor Sultan made a gross mistake, I suggest you or Ibrahim Ali go protest in JB.”

Of course there are no nation called Nusantara, Nusantara is word for all Malay Archipellego which encompassed, Malay Peninuslar, Sumatera, Java, Borneo Island, and all island that now are modern day malaysia, Indonesia, Singapore, Brunei. Every island had its own independence sultanate,and rule their territory in their own way, but still we are brothers of same religion, ethnic stock, and culture. Sometime we fight each other some time we at peace, Thats why the malays in peninsular malaya never regards people from sumatera or java as ‘orang asing’ we called them as orang seberang!!!!. They also feel the same way to us.

UMNO goons accept Malays from Indonesia for the political reason, not to embrace brotherhood as you blindly to believe.

Instead of me, you are the one twisting the history, The Johor empire that you called, does not cover the modern Johore state only, it was called Johor Riau, including singapore, Riau and part of sumatera, so its mean that people from Riau also consider Johorean,

Go to hell with your legally speaking, why should we follow border that actually drawn up, by the British or Dutch to divide our people, The Indonesian people never accept Dutch rule, they fight until the end,

Javanese have no rights to be called Johorean either under Dutch or Indonesian government. Most of those Malay immigrants after independence are Indonesians from Java, Padang and Acheh, they are no bonding with Johor.

Of course you bigot only recognize historical facts favorable to you. If Indonesians did not recognize Dutch colonization, Indonesia should return Riau Islands and Southern Sumatra to Johor Sultan.

“British was the master of Malaya before Malaya was independence. They have legitimate rights to keep your ancestors or my ancestors in Malaya. I have to accept whatever decision made by the British”

Master of malaya? Yea they are colonial people, but we are the owner of Malaya, legally Speaking, The Britsh accepts Malay Sultan as soveriegn ruler of every Malay States,

So, you should not condemn late Johor Sultan for accepting Chinese as his subject.

If you disagree British was the old master, you should return Kelantan and Kedah to Thai King because these two states were annexed with threat against Siam by the British colonial government.

Accepts whatever decision by the Britsh? If oyu accept britsh as malaya’s master than why you called your MPAJA/Three Star friends who launch open rebellion against the British during Emergency as freedom fighter?
Asshole i think you only accept decision that give your people, yang menguntungkan kamu sahaja advantage. Your MPAJA struggle was not for benefit of Malaya as a whole, its for chinese benefit only, their fghts was not for independece, but their struggle to establish Chinese domnated communist republic in MALAYA, So if this (Sum Seng) Three stars devil succeed, Malaya and its rightful owner would not achieve independence, They only get new Foreign Imperialism (moving from British Imperialism to Chinese Imperialism), its like come otu from tiger mouth just to fall into crocodile mouth.

MPAJA was invited to London and KL for the WW2 victory parade. My blog has video to prove this statement.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TqwAvS7jJYA

“A book written by a Chinese does not give more weight to your own history. If MPAJA did kill Malays for fun, UMNO is the first party to make use of “Chinese brutality” as their tool to influence Malays”

nak percaya ka tak mau percaya ikut suka lu lah !!!, tapi apa yang pasti orang – orang Melayu – Islam, sama ada di batu Pahat dan Muar di Johor serta di kawasan Sungai Manik, Perak dan beberapa tempat di malaya telah bangkit menentang kezaliman, gerila komunis Cina yang cuba merampas kuasa di tanah melayu dan mereka telah berjaya menghalang niat jahat parti komunis itu, Jika terdapat ramai orang cina yang terbunuh dalam pertempuran dan pegaduhan yang berlaku, the MPAJA should blame themselves as they are the one who drew the first bllod in that vioelence.

Without the 50,000 troops from British, Australia and New Zealand came to Malaya, your Malay heroic ancestors have no way to defeat communist insurgents.

Of Course UMNO as a malay party is going to remind the malays about chinese butality again and again,One bite always shy. Why we should be less vigilant against a group of people who never sincere to us as history had proved?

Most UMNO leaders are non-Malay blood, they have to instigate local native Malays to hate Chinese for them to grasp power as what the China communist party did in China. Chinese Muslims in China are treated badly as UMNO treats Malaysian Chinese.

matwan says:

arameswara never converted to Islam as written in the textbook’

-There are two school of thought on this matter, some he is the one who convert to Islam, some say his son who succeed him convert to Islam, One way or another, Malacca become a muslim sultanate and so all of their subject- entire malay people of the peninsula, so why the fuss on it.

That is showing your stupidity and bigot. History is based on fact, not based on your present religion and preference.

You are the stupid one, i say they are two school of thought of historian about this matters, some say parameswara convert to Islam, some say they it is his successor who convert,

‘so if the book’s claim about parameswara is wrong. that will be his successor who become Muslim, does it matter now, because eventually entire malay peninsula (malacca kingdom) had become a muslim kingdom, do u think we malay will become hindus if paramswara die as hindu!!!!!’

I don’t care you are muslim or hindu, that is your own business. No religion will change a Malay racist like you to a religious person.

‘Melaka Sultan needed immediate protection from the Ming Emperor against the Siamese King, your Sultan took whatever maid from the inner palace as a princess.’

That ive no comment it is his choice if he want to take princess Hang Li Poh, or maid hang li poh, it his choice,
Regarding ming protection, ok imperial china is a superpower at that time, so malacca need his protection, BUT THAT DOES NOT GIVE FOR THE CHINESE TO CLAIM THAT THEY ORIGINATED FROM MALAYA’ like nowadays many country need seek USA’s protection
but does that mean american white can go to that country and claim that country is theirs?

Your master UMNO cannot accept Hang Li Poh is not a princess. Ming Emperor surname is Chu, not Hang. Ming Emperor is a Han race. I am not sure Han and Hang got any special relationship or not.

Parameswara was not originated from Malacca too. So what is your point? Arab, Indian and Chinese traders reached Malaya earlier than Parameswara if you believe in history.

Those Baba ancestors are subjects of Malacca Sultan as long as Malacca sultanate existence, are they less “bumi” than you? Who is racist and discriminate against Chinese especially Baba?

‘hey are so-called real persons just based on a legendary text, “Malay Annals”. That is not a historical fact, but a “cerita dongeng”.

Perak Sultan owns a kris as it was believed inherited from Hang Tuah, the kris and Hang Tuah remain should be sent for archaeological analysis to prove that he is a real person.’
,
Before this i have heard claim from chinese that hang tuah is a chinese, http://answers.yahoo.com/question/index?qid=20070428001748AAOolFb,
Now another slant eyed asshole claim hangtuah is a non person
lihatlah, betapa busuk dan khianatnya hati orang cina, bukan saja negeri orang melayu mahu dirampas, hero orang melayu yang tidak pernah mengganggu mereka pun nak dirampas. What to say chauvinist.

Whether Hang Tuah and his gang is Chinese, I am not interested.

Malay intellectuals themselves also challenge the authenticity of Hang Tuah from the history perspective.

I point you another clue, if Hang Li Poh with a surname Hang was from China, how about Hang Tuah, Hang Lekiu, etc. with similar Hang surname. But, there is no clan with surname Hang in China.

Anyway, I have no objection if you want to adopt monkey king from Chinese novel as your hero. Just a reminder, Islam is prohibiting you to make Hang Tuah as a super natural hero. Maybe this is reason Hang Tuah chapter was pulled out from the history textbook.

‘Your ancestors should follow Japanese back to Japan land for siding the loser. British actually was very nice to Japanese cohorts like Malay nationalists for no charges against them.’

Why should they go to Japan, they are malay from malaya – land of the malays, or your ancestor are the one who should follow the british back to england, because they are the one who brought you here. The British did not punish those nationalist because of persuassion from malay aristocrat who sided with britsh,

British was the master of Malaya before Malaya was independence. They have legitimate rights to keep your ancestors or my ancestors in Malaya. I have to accept whatever decision made by the British.

”How many so-called Malaysia Malays are rakyat Malaya during world war2? At least a half of Johor Malays are immigrants from Indonesia after WW2, what historical roles they played?

Johor Sultans had appointed Chinese as Kapitan before WW2, meaning Chinese people in Johor were recognized as his subject. My ancestors probably more qualify than many Malays to be called anak Johor.

MPAJA fighetrs were recognized as heroes by British and your Malay Sultans after WW2 is a fact. You a Malay racist hate Chinese is not a secret, but MPAJA is still a part of history in Malaya.”

Yes they are rakyat malaya or more accurately the malay states, because at that time, they malaysia and indonesia does not exist yet, both country were called nusantara island and my ancestor move freely into both domain. Yes Sultan Abu Bakar appoint a chinese as kapitan, and regard chinese as johorean, yes that is the gravest mistake – The sultan sure would never know that decades later, the decendant of this Cbinese would try to seize power and salughter his original subject – the malays during 14 days communist reign of terror.

This Malay bigot is twisting history again. No such nation called Nusantara in the history. That was a Malay empire called Johor in the Nusantara.

Indonesia was under the control of Dutch people. Legally speaking, your ancestors were illegal immigrants unlike my ancestors who were brought in by British and Johor Sultan as legal immigrants.

If you think late Johor Sultan made a gross mistake, I suggest you and Ibrahim Ali go demo in JB.

“Malay racist, you are like UMNO goons created your own history based on illusion. Go create more illusive Malay heroes to boast up your own inferior ego.

MPAJA might crossed the Malacca Straits to kill your ancestors in Indonesia as what you suggested.

Bring out your evidence instead of hearsay to prove MPAJA killed innocent Malays after WW2. Prof. Khoo Kay Lim was openly challenged Malaysia historians to come forward with evidence to substantiate that MPAJA killing innocent Malays.

Yes, I disapprove the unlawful execution by the MPAJA against Japanese cohorts. There was only a Chinese cohort for Japanese was executed by MPAJA in my kampung after WW2”

HMM typical answer from a chinese racist who think his race are angels, i suggest u try to go to the Malay in Batu Pahat and say that Kiai Salleh is only cerita dongeng, i bet they are going beat you up if they do not cut your head off.

Hey man Kiai Salleh is not an illusion he is real person from Batu Pahat who led the malay-muslim martial art force that establish to protect the Malays from communist brutality,
But surely you dont believe me, accusing me to create illusive Malay hero (to satisfy my inferior ego), Im sure, ur hatred towards like Kiai Salleh and his warrior group is due to the fact, they manage to defend Malay village from MAPAJA aggrssion and launch their own brutal counterattack against Chinese guerrilla – often with overwhealming victory, if not Johor would be at the hand of chinese right now.

FYI MR NK khoo, i learn story of Kiai Salleh not from Goverment text book, or Umno text books as you called it, I learn it from scholarly bokk written by A Malaysian Chinese professor, Prof Cheah Boon Kheng fro USM, Penang,

I suggest you read first the book ‘Red Star Over Malaya’ and ‘Sino-Malay Conflict; Communist Vandetta and Islamic Resistance’ before you come to wild conclusion that i create an illusive malay hero or that i create story about MPAJA brutality twards the malays, read those book especially, on the chaoter, of Communist regn of terror and chapter Malay vs MPAJA/Chinese conflict.

im not sure if you are going to accept my argument, i think youll never, because u are chinese first and than malaysian,but i dont care, why should i share an opinion with
A chinese bigot like you who always think my people are lazy, useless and inferior people.

aejarahlah yang menunjukka kepada orang Melayu-Islam apakah sikap sebenar orang cina kepada kami semua dan bagaimanakh cara untuk menghadapi dan berusursan dengan mereka.

A book written by a Chinese does not give more weight to your own history. If MPAJA did kill Malays for fun, UMNO is the first party to make use of “Chinese brutality” as their tool to influence Malays.

Prof Khoo Kay Kim already urged anyone come forward to convince him such story with evidence. I disapprove your story until it’s proven true.

Malay racist, please create more Chinese hatred stories for you to instigate more Malays against Chinese.

matwan says:

‘Parameswara never converted to Islam as written in the textbook’
-There are two school of thought on this matter, some he is the one who convert to Islam, some say his son who succeed him convert to Islam, One way or another, Malacca become a muslim sultanate and so all of their subject- entire malay people of the peninsula, so why the fuss on it.

‘Hang Li Poh is not a princess from China, no official document in the Ming Dynasty said Hang Li Poh is a real princess.’
So what if the malacca sultan want to treat her as chinese princess, that doesn’t matter anyway.

– Hang Tuah and his gang are all illusionary characters, there is no historical evidence to prove they are real characters.
– Well, do u have any evindence that they are not exist?
well may be they are some exxagarated stories about their capabilities, but i think they are still real person. Yea we malays are so damn proud of them, so who u want us to regard as heroes?? jet li?? bruce lee?

The majority of Malay were cohorts working for Japanese Imperial Army during the World War 2 is downplayed.

– Chinese played important role in the resistance against Japanese occupation is ignored.

Well i think ur main focus will be this matter,

majority of malays found no reason to be hostile with japanese army, because they give us no harm. bear in ur racist mind mr nk khoo, malaya was not an independent country before japanese invasion, we the malay-muslim, the real citizen of malaya, subject of malay sultan were colonised by the british, the real reason malay nationalist in KMM sided with the japanese is due to promise of independence by the eastern samuraai (we were cheated of course- but that was the case as other nationalist movement in indonesia and burma).

Chinese played important role in the resistance against Japanese occupation is ignored.
Why should malaysian goverment tell much stories about this MPAJA whose aim is well known- to make malaya as a part of mainland china.
Chinese resistance was not for malaya, it was an extension of sino-japanese war, Most of your people die not defend malaya, but because of japanese hate u!!!! After all why should chinese at that time want to fight for independece malaya, you are not even a citizen of malaya at that time.

Since you are from muar, johor :
There are great possibility u father or grandfather would be one of the chinese who ‘ll rejoice when the japanese surrendur, and than teaming up with Bintang tiga guerrila and chinese gangster to attack and liquidate this so called japanese lackey (read the malays) – slaughter them, behead, abduct and raping malay woman in jungle, burn the mosque, forcing the malay to eat pig etc- These guerilla initally went unchallenge thinking this ‘stupid’ and poorly armed muslim villagers would be unable to resist them, (in the period of 15 August 1945 – 3 September 1945).

Since you are from muar, johor, surely you will heard this
name – Kiyai Salleh and his shuo dao (long knife)
Im sure you are going to despised him because he and his Sabilillah Army group had shown the MPAJA (an other like minded chinese) that there will be terrible reprisal for Malay-muslims’ blood that had been spilled by the communist

nkkhoo says:

‘Parameswara never converted to Islam as written in the textbook’

-There are two school of thought on this matter, some he is the one who convert to Islam, some say his son who succeed him convert to Islam, One way or another, Malacca become a muslim sultanate and so all of their subject- entire malay people of the peninsula, so why the fuss on it.

===

That is showing your stupidity and bigot. History is based on fact, not based on your present religion and preference.

‘Hang Li Poh is not a princess from China, no official document in the Ming Dynasty said Hang Li Poh is a real princess.’

So what if the malacca sultan want to treat her as chinese princess, that doesn’t matter anyway.

====

Melaka Sultan needed immediate protection from the Ming Emperor against the Siamese King, your Sultan took whatever maid from the inner palace as a princess.

– Hang Tuah and his gang are all illusionary characters, there is no historical evidence to prove they are real characters.
– Well, do u have any evindence that they are not exist?

well may be they are some exxagarated stories about their capabilities, but i think they are still real person. Yea we malays are so damn proud of them, so who u want us to regard as heroes?? jet li?? bruce lee?

They are so-called real persons just based on a legendary text, “Malay Annals”. That is not a historical fact, but a “cerita dongeng”.

Perak Sultan owns a kris as it was believed inherited from Hang Tuah, the kris and Hang Tuah remain should be sent for archaeological analysis to prove that he is a real person.

The majority of Malay were cohorts working for Japanese Imperial Army during the World War 2 is downplayed.

– Chinese played important role in the resistance against Japanese occupation is ignored.

Well i think ur main focus will be this matter,

majority of malays found no reason to be hostile with japanese army, because they give us no harm. bear in ur racist mind mr nk khoo, malaya was not an independent country before japanese invasion, we the malay-muslim, the real citizen of malaya, subject of malay sultan were colonised by the british, the real reason malay nationalist in KMM sided with the japanese is due to promise of independence by the eastern samuraai (we were cheated of course- but that was the case as other nationalist movement in indonesia and burma).

Your ancestors should follow Japanese back to Japan land for siding the loser. British actually was very nice to Japanese cohorts like Malay nationalists for no charges against them.

Chinese played important role in the resistance against Japanese occupation is ignored.

Why should malaysian goverment tell much stories about this MPAJA whose aim is well known- to make malaya as a part of mainland china.
Chinese resistance was not for malaya, it was an extension of sino-japanese war, Most of your people die not defend malaya, but because of japanese hate u!!!! After all why should chinese at that time want to fight for independece malaya, you are not even a citizen of malaya at that time.

How many so-called Malaysia Malays are rakyat Malaya during world war2? At least a half of Johor Malays are immigrants from Indonesia after WW2, what historical roles they played?

Johor Sultans had appointed Chinese as Kapitan before WW2, meaning Chinese people in Johor were recognized as his subject. My ancestors probably more qualify than many Malays to be called anak Johor.

MPAJA fighetrs were recognized as heroes by British and your Malay Sultans after WW2 is a fact. You a Malay racist hate Chinese is not a secret, but MPAJA is still a part of history in Malaya.

Since you are from muar, johor :
There are great possibility u father or grandfather would be one of the chinese who ‘ll rejoice when the japanese surrendur, and than teaming up with Bintang tiga guerrila and chinese gangster to attack and liquidate this so called japanese lackey (read the malays) – slaughter them, behead, abduct and raping malay woman in jungle, burn the mosque, forcing the malay to eat pig etc- These guerilla initally went unchallenge thinking this ‘stupid’ and poorly armed muslim villagers would be unable to resist them, (in the period of 15 August 1945 – 3 September 1945).

Since you are from muar, johor, surely you will heard this
name – Kiyai Salleh and his shuo dao (long knife)
Im sure you are going to despised him because he and his Sabilillah Army group had shown the MPAJA (an other like minded chinese) that there will be terrible reprisal for Malay-muslims’ blood that had been spilled by the communist

Malay racist, you are like UMNO goons created your own history based on illusion. Go create more illusive Malay heroes to boast up your own inferior ego.

MPAJA might crossed the Malacca Straits to kill your ancestors in Indonesia as what you suggested.

Bring out your evidence instead of hearsay to prove MPAJA killed innocent Malays after WW2. Prof. Khoo Kay Lim was openly challenged Malaysia historians to come forward with evidence to substantiate that MPAJA killing innocent Malays.

Yes, I disapprove the unlawful execution by the MPAJA against Japanese cohorts. There was only a Chinese cohort for Japanese was executed by MPAJA in my kampung after WW2.